Joanne Brothwell, author
"Eerie, absorbing tales, edged in myth and lore... a fresh take on the supernatural."
 
On the morning of release day for Silencing Breath, I woke up bright and early and full of enthusiasm. I pulled it up on Amazon just to make sure it was there before I started making public proclamations about it. 

Very quickly, my enthusiasm turned to horror. Low and behold, it already had a negative review. 

My knees went weak. My stomach clenched. Tears pricked at the back of my eyes. 
I realize that all authors are going to get their fair share of less than stellar reviews. As my most loyal fan and friend, Ashley Olien, pointed out, "You can be the sweetest peach on the tree, but not everyone likes peaches." So very true. 

Kami Garcia nailed it when she wrote about her experiences with negative feedback: "Writing is scary and lonely, and everyone needs support (and a thick skin)." The problem is, my skin isn't thick. I thought it was, but it isn't. 

What to do? 

First, I had a temper tantrum and made a public announcement that I was going to quit writing (if you want to read it, you can't. I deleted it when my good sense returned). Then, I reached out for support and told everyone I knew how I felt. Most attempted to reassure me. Criticism is normal. No you don't (totally) suck. Yes, this is part of being a writer. 

At this point, I need to move on. I'm going back to revising The Eve Genome, and attempting to turn it from something "very good" to freaking awesome. I am going to watch every single episode of Breaking Bad (Because that dude's life is a disaster). I'm going to blog just because I feel like it. Most importantly, I'm going to stop reading reviews. Stop. It. Now.

Any other advice for me, fellow bloggers? How do you handle criticism?
 


Comments

Rebecca
03/17/2013 5:00pm

Write for yourself. You're your own number 1 fan and so long as you stay standing and have faith in yourself you'll do great things. Look at all the trash people have said about popular books like Twilight and Harry Potter. No matter who you are, you'll get criticized. I don't have a thick skin either. All we can do as writers is take those bad reviews and critiques and turn them into positive energy. I'm so glad you aren't going to quit. I'm excited to read more from you, you have to strive to show those reviews how wrong they are.

Reply
03/19/2013 6:55pm

Thanks, Rebecca. And so true. It's not about the reviews, is it?

Reply
03/18/2013 4:34am

I don't think ANYONE has thick skin. Not really, anyway. Every "word" affects us if we let it. I don't write (outside of my blog), but I design and sew. I try not to give too much thought to everyone's opinions. I'm going to keep doing what I do so long as I love it and it makes me happy. If I never sold a garment, I would keep sewing just to hang dresses on my wall. I think you have to come to a point where you ask yourself, "what makes me happy"? Accept and embrace...then carry on!

Reply
03/19/2013 6:57pm

Hi Katrina,
Yes, I think the key is to remember what makes us happy. I was happy before I started worrying about reviews. It's time to get back to the fun in writing.
Thanks!

Reply
03/18/2013 2:06pm

It's a tough question which is why we all struggle when confronted with negative feedback. Especially when rebuttals only make things worse. We have no recourse. Except to write the next book. Glad to hear your working on Eve! It's a great story!

Reply
03/19/2013 6:58pm

Great point, Karyn.
It is hard to accept the fact that there is no recourse. Not easy to just have to grin and bear it.

Reply
04/09/2013 1:11am

I like This
Thks

Reply



Leave a Reply


Joanne Brothwell, author